16 Comments

The tragedy of war is that most of the people involved are not monsters.

Expand full comment

I know. I know.

Expand full comment

While reading this post I kept thinking of a recent documented incident that took place in India of a jaguar that was chasing down a dog, only to find itself locked in a bathroom with its potential prey. They spent the night in separate corners. Who can say why the jaguar didn't attack the dog then. I suspect there are moments in the animal world, too, when a trapped body recognizes itself in another.

https://gurunanaksewadal.com/a-tale-of-unlikely-companionship-when-a-leopard-and-a-dog-shared-an-unusual-encounter/

Expand full comment

yes, this piece deserves its own post. "the knot of us" comes through so clearly, it made me examine how i hold those conflicting impulses too. especially now. mostly i'm just so damn sad. still appreciate you sharing, along with those other links.

Expand full comment

Thank you Mary

Expand full comment

Thank you for this.

Expand full comment

Thanks, Mary.

Expand full comment

I can’t tell you how much I needed this.

Expand full comment

while 100 humans still languish in tunnels, more than an year after the most viscous slaughter of Jewsnfor being Jews, there is still so little horror and rage about that and we let the false narrative that this is about land rights continue… asking people to hold room in their heart that these are not monsters? babies burned alive, women raped till their pelvises broke? these are the hard things to think about and yet here’s another piece damning Israel.

Expand full comment

Yet another emotional (i.e., not rational) response to a complex situation. Dropping millions of racist Europeans in an Asian country based on a book written thousands of years ago was never going to be a straightforward operation. They stole thousands (or millions) of hectares of someone else's country and expect to be called victims, because some relative was murdered by other Europeans. History didn't stop because some people were forced off their land by Romans. Calling land rights a false narrative is very telling.

Expand full comment

don’t know where to start with this… hebrews are indigenous to this land

arabs were given many opportunities for sharing the land and they’ve rejected every one and their dogma calls for genocide

and calling jewish refugees from WW2 racist europeans is a new low

Expand full comment

Calling Hebrews indigenous to the area is interesting. Got any proof...other than your own words? I'm not accepting Hebrew scriptures for that purpose, because they are rather self-serving. Genetic testing is outlawed in Israel. I wonder why?

Expand full comment

That is a complete falsehood.

Expand full comment

How so?

Expand full comment

"Yet another emotional (i.e., not rational) response to a complex situation" -- Yep

"Dropping millions of racist Europeans in an Asian country based on a book written thousands of years ago was never going to be a straightforward operation" -- This is supposed to be rational? You two deserve each other!

Expand full comment

I’ve just re read this piece and the comments. It’s too bad

Expand full comment